Routine Maintenance
I recently was reading some comments on dietgirl about the difficulty of maintaining weight loss, and most of the people were expressing a great deal of frustration and resignation. Its totally easy to understand where these folks are coming from -- the lack of support and information about healthy weight maintenance is definitely a pet peeve of mine. At the same time, a lot of what the bloggers were saying had to do with the fact that its 'easier' to lose weight. So, let me posit something here. My guess (based on personal experience) is that sometimes we think (at least some aspects of) weight loss are easy because we feel we're doing something that's temporary. So saying no to that donut, turning down Mom's special stuffing, skipping the office outing -- these are all things that we can do... at least once. Going for a mile run, taking the stairs, parking the car farther away -- again, things that we can do... at least for now. Joining a program, keeping a food log, participating in a support group -- definitely doable ... for this week, anyway. Skipping dessert? Pushing your exercise boundaries? Engaging in new introspective meditation? Well, you get the picture. But what happens the first time you wake up really tired and cranky and are hankering for a chocolate sundae? What happens to that exercise program when the weather goes bad, our ankles start to hurt, or we miss watching our favorite TV program. How many times can you say no to food offerings, especially from relatives, especially during the holidays? Can we really practice that kind of discipline for ever and ever and ever? Well, maybe YOU can. But not me. I don't have the heart (or the stomach) for cutting out all of my favorite foods, and while I like taking stairs, there are times when I'd rather ride the escalator. I enjoy biking to work, but I'm not above using my car when necessary. Last week, I skipped my regular LONG weekend run because, well, because I just FELT LIKE IT! This morning at Peets, I gave in to scone-mania and just HAD one! My food journal, meticulously kept from November to March, has all kinds of gaps and holes and missing days in April. But STOP! I have good news. No. Really. The fact is, that we don't have to be perfect. We don't have to always turn down food, and we don't have to always say yes to exercise. In fact, to be a maintainer, we don't actually have to MAINTAIN! Here's what I'm driving at. If you do temporary things to lose weight, you might lose weight temporarily. To lose weight and maintain that loss for the long haul, you don't have to keep doing everything you did at the beginning, so long as you continue to introduce new behaviors. Let's face it, until the 'cure' comes along, all we really have to do for maintenance is find a mixture of things that we can stick with, one day at a time, who's effect is to balance our caloric intake with our caloric expenditure. Its not only impossible to keep 'dieting' forever, its not worth it! So the food and/or exercise that works for you today, only has to work for you today. It might work tomorrow, and the day after, but I can pretty much guarantee it won't work forever. So each day, we just have to be open to the idea of something different. We might only end up adopting one or two new things every month or so. But week after week, year after year, we need a variety of strategies that help us feel free, in control and successful. Its a tall order. But life isn't a still photo. Its an organic, ever-changing process. So stick with it, keep an open mind, and (most of all) send in your suggestions! |
4 Comments:
Hi, Jonathan! :)
'We don't have to be perfect." Yup. We can't be perfect, 'cause we humans! Humans make mistakes! Ease up on yerselves!
Really.
As for maintainence? Well I'm nowhere near there, not yet. But I have been before. :) Seems to me that it's easier to "maintain" a weight loss if we acheive the loss through behaviors we can keep up for the rest of our lives. If running isn't your thing, than don't depend on it to maintain a weightloss. Go dancing, instead. Or something.
As for the foood issues. yeah, I'm one of those people who has no trouble turning down offers of food. "Oh that looks so delicious! Thank you, but I just can't eat another bite right now." That sort of thing usually works just fine. If they insist, then they hear about how my tummy get upset if I eat more than a certain amount. :)
By QuinnLaBelle, at 6:09 AM
That is so brilliant! I spotted you on thelosthawaiin. I am looking forward to hearing what else you have to say. Thanks, Melissa
By 3:20 PM
, at
Yeah, maintainence is really hard, WAY harder than losing. Maybe I'm only saying that because I've forgotten how hard it was to lose. :)
I definitely agree with what you are saying; you can't expect yourself to always stick to the strict rules that helped you lose weight.
What has worked for me is a trigger weight: I'm relatively flexible and loose when I'm below that trigger weight, but I go back to a stricter regimine when I creep above that trigger weight. It has worked well for me for several years.
I got the idea from The Hacker's Diet. This is the chapter where he talks about trigger weights: http://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/e4/forever.html
i loved this post, it is so reassuring after all those maintenance horror stories i got in my comments! i was starting to feel worried that i wasn't worried about maintenance.
i was also reassured by what you said about it being an ever-changing process! i am always changing my tactics and discovering new ways to exercise etc. i guess that's just being curious and adventurous about life, rather than making it all about a Torturous Weight Loss Regime.
(nice photo on the sidebar there, by the way mate... phwoar! ;)
By 12:35 PM
, at